Title Odgovornost prijevoznika za smrt i tjelesne ozljede putnika - međunarodni i nacionalni propisi : doktorska disertacija
Title (english) Responsibility of carrier for death and physical injury to passengers -international and national regulations
Author Mara Barun
Mentor Dorotea Ćorić (mentor)
Committee member Vesna Tomljenović (predsjednik povjerenstva)
Committee member Dorotea Ćorić (član povjerenstva)
Committee member Dragan Bolanča (član povjerenstva)
Granter University of Rijeka FACULTY OF LAW Rijeka
Defense date and country 2012-07-30, Croatia
Scientific / art field, discipline and subdiscipline SOCIAL SCIENCES Law
Universal decimal classification (UDC ) 347.79 - Maritime law. Laws of shipping, of inland navigation
Abstract U ovoj doktorskoj disertaciji, autorica razmatra problematiku odgovornosti prijevoznika za smrt i tjelesne ozljede putnika u pomorskom prijevozu, unutarnjoj plovidbi, zračnom, cestovnom te željezničkom prijevozu u odnosu na međunarodne konvencije, hrvatske nacionalne propise te propise EU. U uređenju predmetne materije i na međunarodnoj i nacionalnoj razini zapažamo tendenciju, s jedne strane povećanja iznosa na ime naknade štete u korist korisnika usluga dok je s druge strane prijevoznik zaštićen na način da je gubitak prava na ograničenje odgovornosti tek namjera ili dolus eventualis. S tim u vezi je i funkcija osiguranja od odgovornosti prijevoznika koja se također temelji na načelima ograničenja odgovornosti. Uvodi se institut izravne tužbe (actio directa) prema kojem se oštećenik za naknadu štete može izravno obratiti osiguratelju i dobiti satisfakciju u granicama odgovornosti prijevoznika. Posebno smo istaknuli rad na unifikaciji prijevoznog prava u odnosu na ugovore o prijevozu putnika i utvrdili da je snažno prisutan gotovo sto godina (Varšavska konvencija iz 1929. god.). Noviji međunarodni instrumenti uvode dvostupanjski sustav odgovornosti što je značajna novost u prijevoznom pravu. U prvom stupnju prijevoznik odgovara objektivno na temelju uzročnosti a u drugom stupnju njegova odgovornost temelji se na pretpostavljenoj krivnji (Montrealska konvencija iz 1999. god. te Atenska konvencija iz 2002. god.).
Posebna pozornost posvećena je usklađenosti nacionalnih pravnih propisa s međunarodnim konvencijama kao i propisima EU. Nacionalni propisi u velikoj mjeri zadovoljavaju međunarodne pravne standarde. Propisi EU kao poseban pravni sustav u cijelosti implementiraju rješenja međunarodnih konvencija u pogledu odgovornosti prijevoznika za smrt i tjelesne ozljede putnika čime se postiže visok stupanj unifikacije a time i kvalitetnija pravna zaštita u postupcima naknade štete.
U cjelini uzevši možemo zaključiti da je u području odgovornosti pravno najuređenija grana zračnog prijevoza u međunarodnom i domaćem pravu. Moramo naglasiti nužnost revizije međunarodne konvencije za cestovni prijevoz putnika te donošenje novog međunarodnog instrumetna koji bi regulirao prijevoz putnika unutarnjim vodama. Što se tiče hrvatskog zakonodavstva prijeko je potrebno donijeti novi propis iz područja cestovnog prijevoza i prijevoza unutarnjim vodama. Autorica se ujedno zalaže za ujednačen sustav odgovornosti odnosno istu pravnu poziciju prijevoznika i putnika u svim granama prijevoza. Krajnji cilj pravnog uređenja ovog važnog instituta jest poboljšanje postojećih pravnih rješenja na način njihove prilagodbe zahtjevima i potrebama suvremenog načina života te se pro futuro predlaže inzistiranje na širokoj prihvaćenosti međunarodnopravnih rješenja što je uvjet uspješnog odvijanja i daljnjeg razvoja prijevozne djelatnosti kao i veće sigurnosti za ostvarivanja prava na naknadu štete u korist oštećenika.
Abstract (english) In this doctoral thesis, the problem areas of carrier responsibility for death and physical injury to passengers in sea transport, domestic navigation, air, and road and rail transport are analysed in relation to international conventions, Croatian regulations and the regulations of the EU. In ordering the subject matter, both at an international and national level, we noted the tendency, on the one hand to increase the amount of compensation in the service user's favour while on the other hand the carrier is protected in such a way that that the loss of rights to limited liability is just intention or dolus eventualis. Related to this is the function of insurance against carrier responsibility which is also based on the principles of limited liability. The institute of direct lawsuits (actio directa) where the injured party can directly approach the insurer and gain satisfaction within the limits of carrier responsibility is also introduced
Particularly, work on the unification of transport law in relation to passenger transport contract is emphasised. We also established that it has been powerfully present for almost 100 years (Warsaw Convention of 1929). More recent international instruments have introduced a two-tier system of responsibility which is significantly new in transport law. At the first level, the carrier is responsible objectively on the basis of causality and at the second level responsibility is based on presumed guilt. (Montreal Convention of 1999 and the Athens Convention of 2002).
Particular attention is paid to the harmonisation of national legal regulations from international conventions as well as those of the EU. National regulations to a great extent satisfy international legal standards. EU regulations as a special legal system within the overall implemented solutions of international conventions regarding the responsibility of carriers for the death and physical injury to passengers by which a high level of unification is achieved and consequently there is more quality legal protection in compensation procedure.
Overall, we can conclude that in the area of responsibility the most legally regulated branch is air transport both in domestic and international law. The necessity for review of the international convention for road transport is emphasised as well as the bringing in of new international instruments which would regulate passenger transport in domestic waters. As far as Croatian legislation is concerned, it is absolutely necessary to enact new regulations in the area of road transport and transport in domestic waters. The author also purports a unified system of responsibility, that is, the same legal position for both carrier and passenger in all areas of transport.
The final aim of legal regulation of this important institute is the improvement of existing legal solutions so that they are adapted to the demands and needs of our modern way of life and pro futuro it is suggested that international solutions be widely accepted which is the precondition for successful transport activity and development and to increasing assure that the injured party achieves rights to compensation.
Keywords
odgovornost
prijevoz
prijevoznik
putnik
smrt
tjelesne ozljede
međunarodni i nacionalni propisi
Keywords (english)
responsibility
transport
carrier
passengers
death
physical injury
international and national regulation
Language croatian
URN:NBN urn:nbn:hr:188:445515
Study programme Title: Postgraduate Doctoral Study Programme in the field of Social Sciences, the subject of Law Study programme type: university Study level: postgraduate Academic / professional title: doktor/doktorica pravnih znanosti, područje društvenih znanosti, polje pravo (doktor/doktorica pravnih znanosti, područje društvenih znanosti, polje pravo)
Catalog URL https://libraries.uniri.hr/cgi-bin/unilib.cgi?form=D1130216058
Type of resource Text
Extent 335 str.
File origin Born digital
Access conditions Closed access
Terms of use
Created on 2017-01-19 17:09:50